Regency Townhomes

860 Marquette Ave, Muskegon, MI 49442
$6,250,000 Price
$130,000 Price Per Unit
6.80% Cap Rate
7.66% Pro Forma Cap Rate
48 Number of Units
$106 Price per Square Foot

The Property

  • Regency Townhomes is a premier 48-unit townhome community located in Muskegon, Michigan. The property offers a rare "big-box" rental experience with spacious two- and three-bedroom floor plans that are approximately 60% larger than those of the local competitive set. Residents enjoy a high-quality living environment featuring open-concept layouts, direct-entry access, individual addresses, and private patios. Each unit is further enhanced by practical amenities, including an attached garage and an in-unit washer and dryer, providing the privacy and feel of a single-family home rather than a traditional apartment.

Property Overview

  • The property was built in two phases, in 2000 and 2011, and has 32 townhome units, and 16 apartment units: The 16 apartment units are two bedroom one bath (one level, upstairs). The 32 townhomes units are 3 bedroom one bath (two level). For the three bedroom units, a sliding door off the main floor opens onto a private patio that backs up to a large lawn, which is well suited to pets. For the two bedroom units, there is a balcony on the top level at the rear of the unit. Upstairs, each unit has two or three bedrooms, each with a large closet, plus a full bath. Interiors are mostly original, though several units already have updated appliances and vinyl flooring. Each unit has its own water heater, furnace, air conditioner, and in-unit washer and dryer. Gas and electric are metered separately for each unit and billed directly to the tenants. Water runs through a single master meter and is recovered through a monthly water fee. Tenants pay all utilities.

Rent Comparisons and Revenue Upside

  • Regency Townhomes is leased below market in every floor plan. The 16 two-bedroom units average $1,242 a month against a market rent of $1,300, and the 31 three-bedroom units average $1,395 against $1,595. That gap of roughly $175 per unit per month, about 11%, is the core of the opportunity. Bringing leases up to market through normal turnover and renewals raises gross scheduled rent from $774,420 to $862,080. That adds about $87,660 a year in revenue without a capital renovation program. These market rents are already proven at the property - as $1,300 and $1,595 is the highest achieving rent for a 2 bedroom and 3 bedroom unit.
  • Targeted renovations offer clear upside to market rents. The buildings were constructed in 2000 and 2011, and the interiors remain largely original. An exterior refresh paired with interior upgrades would attract tenants willing to pay a premium. On the exterior, the addition of private patios would enhance curb appeal and tenant amenities. On the interior, upgrades would include granite or quartz countertops, new cabinetry, and luxury vinyl plank flooring in place of the existing first-floor carpet and tile, which is now the market standard. Renovated townhomes with garages in Muskegon currently command rents of up to $2,000 per month. A renovation program would increase returns, extend the life of the asset, and lower turnover costs.

Replacement Cost / Basis

  • At $130,208 per unit and $106 per square foot, Regency Townhomes is offered far below what it would cost to build today. Current benchmarks put hard costs alone for wood-frame garden-style multifamily at $150–$250 per square foot. Soft costs typically add another 15–25%. That puts new construction of a comparable 48-unit townhome community above $10 million, or more than $210,000 per unit, before land, site work and attached garages. Because new competing supply is hard to make work financially, occupancy and rent growth are protected. A buyer gets a scarce townhome product at roughly 50% of replacement cost.

  • Regency Townhomes is located minutes from downtown Muskegon, Muskegon Lake, and the Lake Michigan shoreline. Downtown Muskegon is in the middle of a major revitalization. Projects include lakefront mixed-use developments like Adelaide Pointe, Viridian Shores, and Harbor 31, the new Element by Marriott hotel, and the Shaw Walker redevelopment. Dozens of new restaurants, bars, and shops have opened along Western Avenue, and downtown foot traffic keeps growing year over year. More construction is planned, including a proposed 5-story, 40-unit mixed-use building near downtown, which points to continued demand for quality rental housing in the market.
  • Muskegon County has about 176,000 residents and a median household income of roughly $65,000 per year. Major employers include Trinity Health (4,000 employees), Howmet Aerospace (2,700), and ADAC Automotive (1,000+). The median home sale price in Muskegon reached about $241,600 in early 2026, up 7.5% year over year. With today's rates, taxes, and insurance, that works out to an estimated $1,900 monthly payment, about $600 more than Regency's $1,294 average rent. As home prices rise, more households are pushed toward renting. Regency's large townhomes with attached garages offer a single-family feel at a lower monthly cost.

Location & Neighborhood

Copyright © CREOP, LLC. All Rights Reserved.